Independent Contractor vs. Employee: Definition and
Status
Free Info on our recommended Medical Transcription Program leading to an exciting home based medical transcription career
Employee or Independent Contractor?
There is an important legal distinction
between an employee and an independent contractor. The IRS
has strict definitions for independent contractors and for
good reason. Independent contractors are typically exempt
from standard labor and employment legislation. Improper classification
can result in under-reporting of wages, unemployment taxes,
benefits, etc., all of which can bring about devestating financial
and legal consequenses.
If you choose to operate as an independent
contractor, you must be certain that you understand the requirements
for such an election and that you comply with them. Failure
to do so may result in a disallowance of your status by the
IRS and lead to financial penalties and possible legal action.
However, if you plan carefully and
maintain complete documentation, you should have no problems.
Definition of an Independent Contractor
Unfortunately, there is no short
concise definition of an independent contractor that can be
applied across a broad range of employment situations. However,
the most basic premise of determination relates to the degree
to which an employer is able to exercise control over the
worker. Other factors include the nature of the service provided,
and the independence of the worker.
Free Info on our recommended Medical Transcription Program leading to an exciting home based medical transcription career
Basic Test for Determining Independent
Contractor Status
A first step would to be evaluate
your situation relative to the following very basic criteria.
1. An independent contractor
must be continuously and permanently free from control or
direction over the performance of duties and services, both
under his contract of service and in fact; AND
2. The services of an independent
contractor must fall outside the usual course of business
for which the services are performed OR the services must
be performed outside of all the places of business of the
enterprise for which services are being performed; AND
3. An independent contractor
is someone who is operating in an independently established
trade, occupation, profession or business.
20 IRS Guidelines for Establishing Independent
Contractor Status
The following guidelines have been
provided by the IRS to assist in properly classifying workers
as independent contractors. The common denominator is the
extent to which the employer is able to exercise direction
and control over the activities of the worker. As the language
below suggests, there is a significant amount of subjectivity
in determining final status - and of course the IRS has the
final say.
1. INSTRUCTIONS
If the employing unit gives detailed
instructions, particularly regarding how the task is to be
accomplished, the worker is more likely to be an
employee. If the employing unit only gives instructions as
to the final outcome, the worker is more likely to be an independent
contractor.
2. TRAINING
If the worker requires additional
training from the employing unit, he/she is more likely to
be an employee. If the worker requires no additional
training, he/she is more likely to be an independent contractor.
3. INTEGRATION
The more the services performed
by the worker are closely related to the "core"
business of the employing unit, the more likely the worker
is an
employee. The more the services performed by the worker are
incidental to "core" business practices, the more
likely the worker is an independent
contractor.
4. SERVICES RENDERED PERSONALLY
If the services must be rendered
by the worker personally, he/she is more likely to be an employee.
If the worker need not perform the services personally, he/she
is more likely to be an independent contractor.
5. SET HOURS OF WORK
If the worker has set hours of
work, he/she is more likely to be an employee. If the worker
is able to set his or her own hours, he/she is more likely
to be an independent contractor.
6. CONTINUING RELATIONSHIP
The longer the business relationship
continues, the more likely the worker is an employee. The
shorter the business relationship continues, the
more likely the worker is an independent contractor.
7. CONTRACTING, SUPERVISING,
AND PAYING ASSISTANTS
If the employing unit is responsible
for contracting, supervising, and paying assistants, the worker
is more likely to be an employee. If the worker is responsible
for contracting, supervising, and paying assistants, he/she
is more likely to be an independent contractor.
8. FULL-TIME WORK REQUIRED
If the worker is required to work
full-time, he/she is more likely to be an employee. If the
worker is able to set his or her own hours, he/she is more
likely to be an independent contractor.
9. SEQUENCE OF WORK
If the employing unit establishes
the sequence of work to be performed, the worker is more likely
to be an employee. If the worker determines the sequence,
he/she is more likely to be an independent contractor.
10. PLACE OF WORK
If the work must be performed at
the place of business, the worker is more likely to be an
employee. If the work may be performed elsewhere, the worker
is more likely to be an independent contractor.
11. REPORTS
If the worker has to make frequent
reports on the progress of his or her services, he/she is
more likely to be an employee. If the worker does not
have to make frequent reports, he/she is more likely to be
an independent contractor.
12. METHOD OF PAYMENT
If the worker is paid from company
payroll, he/she is more likely to be an employee. If the worker
bills the employing unit, he/she is more likely to be an independent
contractor.
13. RISK OF LOSS
If the worker has little risk of
loss, he/she is more likely to be an employee. If the worker
has a greater risk of loss, he/she is more likely to an
independent contractor.
14. FURNISHING TOOLS AND MATERIALS
If the employing unit furnishes
tools and materials, the worker is more likely to be an employee.
If the worker furnishes his or her own tools and materials,
he/she is more likely to be an independent contractor.
15. INVESTMENT
If there is little or no personal
investment in the tools, materials, and resources used in
providing the service, the worker is more likely to be an
employee. If the worker has a substantial personal investment,
he/she is more likely to be an independent contractor.
16. PAYMENT OF BUSINESS EXPENSES
If the employing unit directly
pays for a business expense of the worker, the worker is more
likely to be an employee. If the worker pays for business
expenses then bills the employing unit, he/she is more likely
to be an independent contractor.
17. WORKING FOR MORE THAN ONE
FIRM AT A TIME
If the worker provides services
for only the employing unit, he/she is more likely to be an
employee. If the worker serves more than one firm at a time,
he/she is more likely to be an independent contractor.
18. AVAILABILITY OF SERVICES
TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC
If the workerís services
are available only to the employing unit, he/she is more likely
to be an employee. If the worker provides services to the
general public, he/she is more likely to be an independent
contractor.
19. RIGHT TO DISCHARGE
If the employer has the right to
terminate the worker at any time, he/she is more likely to
be an employee. If the employer does not have the right to
terminate the contract without reasonable notice, the worker
is more likely to be an independent contractor.
20. RIGHT TO QUIT
If the worker has the right to quit
without notice, he/she is more likely to be an employee. If
the worker does not have the right to quit without
reasonable notice, he/she is more likely to be an independent
contractor.
Free Info on our recommended Medical Transcription Program leading to an exciting home based medical transcription career
|